India’s Touts: Journal Entry, Day 75

By Iain Manley Apr 19, 2011

Allahaba boatman

I wrote this while watching the World Cup semi final between India and Pakistan, hoping – in my anger – that Pakistan would win. They didn’t.

It has been a day of spitting mad anger over the difference between seventy and one hundred rupees. Although I promised myself – when we arrived in India, fresh after three years away – that I would not, I am again fighting over paltry sums of money. Claire and I might be careful, might watch ten rupees here and there, but our anger isn’t about the amounts we are asked to spend. We are angry because wherever we go, people expect us to give them money for nothing. In North India, we have been gaped at and gawked at and asked for photographs, but rarely treated like guests.

Today we went to Allahabad’s Sangam: the meeting point of the Yamuna, Ganges and mythical Saraswati. We were accosted by beggars as soon as we arrived, beggars that ignored every single passing local. There is a Mughal fort beside the Sangam. We went in. When I knelt to take a photograph of the afternoon light in a stone passageway, I was screamed at in Hindi by a beggar woman and a Brahmin, officiating at a nearby shrine. The only word I recognized, as it was yelled over and over again, was photo.

Photography is so vehemently disallowed because the fort is used by the Indian army. The small section visitors are allowed into contains an underground temple, the first records of which date back to the twelfth century. The stairs going down to it are past a banyan tree that people threw themselves off of, believing that if they died from the fall they would achieve moksha – until Akbar, the Moghul Emperor, banned the practice.

Long before we reached the temple’s entrance we were shouted at again, told to do what we already knew we must: take off our shoes. We were then told to pay a temple maintenance charge by seven fat Brahmins, sitting counting change. I refused, angrily forcing my feet back into my sandals. There was no sign. The fee was an invention. One of the Brahmins relented, telling us to “go, go, go.”

The temple was a cluttered maze of idols placed between carved pillars. There were three statues of Shiva, sitting in lotus position on a tiger pelt, along with strange anteater gods and  jackal-headed figurines. There were priests at intervals in the maze. They clutched at us aggressively, waved fly-whisks over our heads and asked for cash. We moved quickly and exited. A grey haired man was now sitting beside our shoes, demanding baksheesh. Pariah dogs lay about the compound, on stone slabs that covered the temple’s air vents. I remarked to Claire, as we made our way out of the fort, that they were surprisingly well treated: none were emaciated, mangy or hand-shy.

We walked down to the Yamuna’s banks, to hire the rowboat that would take us to float on the rippling water of the Sangam. Auto-rickshaw drivers touted their services as we passed: “Ricksha? You want ricksha? One hundred and fifty rupees.” We approached the empty boats stacked up on the river bank cautiously, like soldiers expecting an ambush. I noticed a sign that looked like a list of prices, but could only read the numbers; the rest was in Hindi and would be no help.

It started: sadhus, boatmen and sellers of cheap religious trinkets noticed us and rushed forward, competing for our attention by placing themselves squarely in our path, by shouting or grasping at our clothes.

“You want boat?”
“Please baba!”
“Saheb! Saheb, you look here!”
“You go Sangam? You take boat?”
“Saheb! You look! Good price!”

My strategy was to stride up and down, ignoring everyone, until the first wave had passed. I then made a single, furtive enquiry. The first price for two people was eight hundred rupees. I laughed. A second boatman offered us his tired looking dingy for six hundred rupees. When I paused to consider the offer, and eventually said “six hundred is too much,” a tout intervened. “Four hundred! I give you four hundred rupees!” Nobody would go any lower. We stood on the bank, waiting for a better price.

A boat returned carrying a middle-aged, middle class Indian couple. When the man disembarked, I asked what he had paid. The boatmen and touts understood, and shouted over me in Hindi. His answer was disappointing: “Four hundred rupees, divided by two.”

I didn’t take the hint. The man waited until his wife was off the boat and, as he was leaving, said, “Did I make myself clear? Four hundred rupees, divided by two.” Divided was a word the boatmen and touts would not understand; a code, used because he was worried what the consequences of helping us might be.

We haggled. Eventually, a boatmen with two waiting passengers agreed to take Claire and I onto the Sangam for one hundred rupees per person. Our middle-class confidant and his wife had paid the same amount for a boat of their own, but in India foreigners are all considered rich and price is subjective. It was a small victory, and I was glad to watch the crowd of scavengers on the river bank slowly recede.

Our boatman was not past hoping that we would pull out wallets fat with foreign money: he began the familiar wheedling of somebody providing a service. Every dip of his oars was a special favour, for which we were expected to tip. When I took photographs of a passing boat, it was because he had brought us up to it. The same was true of a platform I stepped onto at the Sangam: he had not noticed it until I nudged past him, towards it, but as soon as I did, he had stopped just there, just for me.

The passengers on our boat were men in their late thirties or early forties. One was large, with pale skin and a bald, sweaty brow. The other was smaller, darker, with a moustache and humorous, intelligent eyes. They conformed to the Indian stereotype: the tall man with light skin was from Jaipur, in the north, the dark skinned man from Bangalore, in the south. Both were studying for an MBA at Allahabad University and spoke English well.

The man from the north asked if we liked India. We were used to the question. It was asked by everybody, usually in the bright, smiling certainty that we would say yes. “It’s a difficult place,” said Claire, after a moment’s pause.

The northerner nodded. He had watched us fight to be treated fairly on the river bank. His explanation was predictable. “Many people in India,” he said, “have no education.” It was true: literacy rates in India are appalling. Too many people are left scrabbling about on the bottom, where compensation is meagre and competition brutal. And we are treated better by educated Indians, some of whom have opened their homes to us. The conversation developed, and Claire was soon describing how much easier we found travelling in the more literate south. This pleased the Bangalore man, but I wasn’t satisfied placing all the blame for North India’s incivility on education. In Syria, Claire and I were treated like honoured guests by simple people – even by the owners of tea shops, juice bars and taxis, the same people who were treating us badly here, in Allahabad. If education was the sole explanation for people’s behaviour, where did that leave culture?

The Yamuna and Ganges met at an almost perpendicular angle, but the Sangam was set back, off a small spar of land on the Yamuna, just before it was swallowed up by the Ganges. The water was shallow, and I realised that we could have walked here and been only a few metres from the boatloads of Hindus and the Brahmins wading between them.

The boatman rowed us back. He asked halfheartedly for baksheesh when we disembarked. I thanked him, but gave him nothing extra; I was already bracing myself for our next task: haggling an acceptable fare for the journey back to our hotel out of an auto-rickshaw driver. The MBA students told us we should pay forty rupees; we had had paid seventy to get here, but there were only three autos waiting, and they worked together. None would go lower than Rs. 150. When I walked away, towards an unmanned auto, a small, cross-eyed driver pursued me. “I give you one hundred rupees,” he said, once we were out of his colleagues’ earshot. I reluctantly accepted his price, but said to Claire, as we clambered into the vehicle, that I didn’t like the look of the man. He was not just squint. His eyes were bloodshot and bleary; he seemed drunk.

We wove back past the fort, collecting another passenger – who sat in front, beside the driver – near its entrance. A few hundred metres down the road, the driver stopped his rickshaw. “What your hotel name?” he asked.

He already knew the answer, but we told him again.

“JK Palace?” he repeated. “Two hundred and fifty rupees!”

The driver did not just know our hotel’s name. Claire had told him the name of the area it was in – an area that was not far from the city centre – before we agreed on a price. We stomped out of his vehicle and started walking back to the river bank, to try our luck with another driver. The man shouted lower prices at us as we walked, then turned around and followed us back.

There was only one auto left on the river bank. The driver would not accept less than Rs. 150. Although the man’s English didn’t extend past numbers, Claire was shouting at him – shouting things like, “Just because we are foreigners you think we’re rich and stupid” – when a portly man with three women in tow approached us.

“These people are our guests,” he said to the driver. “We must show them our hospitality.”

At last, I thought, somebody was going to help us. The man quickly knocked the price down to one hundred rupees, then he and the three women got in with us. They were, he explained, going in the same direction as us, and if we didn’t mind waiting at for a few minutes at a temple en route, we could share the auto. We were soon buzzing along, telling the women that we were from South Africa and had been in India for three months.

The rickshaw stopped at beside the fort, at a gate we had missed. The group got out. “You wait here,” said the man. “We will be five, ten minutes. Then the rickshaw will drop us and take you to your hotel. You will pay one hundred rupees.” He walked off. The three women fell in behind him.

I stood for a minute, processing what he had said. We would wait for him. We would pay. The man who had appeared talking of hospitality was, I realized, acting as our agent. He had extracted a better price from the driver on our behalf and in exchange expected a free ride. Claire and I found ourselves stomping out of a rickshaw hot-headed once again.

The India we were stuck in looked unfriendly. Beggars – sitting in a line at the temple’s entrance – watched us greedily. A girl was despatched by her mother to trail us. She pulled on our trousers, flashed a gap toothed smile and extended a hand. There were no other autos; in the meantime, ours had mounted the curb. The driver was pursuing us across the pavement, demanding payment for the short distance already covered, shouting, “You pay twenty rupees! You twenty! She twenty!”

We weren’t sure which direction to go in – but we were striding anyway, shouting insults back – when an overloaded rickshaw zipped around the corner and stopped. “Seventy rupees!” shouted the driver, who I recognised. He had also been on the river bank, demanding one hundred and fifty rupees from us. Without talking, we both got in, in front, beside the driver and another passenger – four of us squeezed into a space intended for two.

Claire was furthest to the left. Her left arm and part of her left leg were dangling out of the auto. We pulled away, but the driver of our second auto, the auto we shared with the portly man and the three women, cut us off. He was waving his fist at Claire, still demanding twenty rupees. We tried to manoeuvre around him, but he pulled further out into the road. I could see only one solution: I got out and stood in front of the second auto, glaring at its driver, then directed the third auto, with Claire in it, to go around me. As it passed, I jumped in.

We drove slowly into town. Sunset and the start of the balmy Indian night took the edge off my anger. When we were told to get off at an unfamiliar intersection, even though the driver had said he would take us to our hotel, I didn’t protest. We got into a cycle rickshaw without negotiating a price, because there wasn’t far to go. We knew that cycle-rickshaws over short distances cost twenty rupees and trying to confirm the price sometimes made things more difficult: the driver might read uncertainty in our request and take advantage of it. But when I handed the driver twenty and he said thirty, smiling at me pathetically, I shouted “Fuck off!” and walked away.

I immediately regretted it, and I regret it now, while I half-watch the cricket and sip a cold beer in an upmarket pub. Cycle-rickshaw drivers do not own their vehicles and sleep in the street. They are skinny, uneducated men doing the work of animals and engines. This man thought ten rupees was nothing to me and a lot to him, and he was right. There have also been so many opportunities for misunderstandings, so many things I might have misinterpreted, all through today. But I am tired of being treated as if I owe Indians something extra, something more than their rich countrymen, after spending more than a year in total here, travelling rough. This bias is deeply rooted, right to the nation’s top: foreigners pay twenty, thirty and forty times more than any local to enter India’s sites, by government decree. And I am not just tired – I am angry too. Angry because every time I am treated without courtesy – reduced to a foreign wallet, stacked with undeserved cash – I am also dehumanised. If somebody treats me as an object, as something that doesn’t need or deserve empathy, am I not entitled to act in kind, and see nothing but an engine or an animal or some other thing?

If you enjoyed India’s Touts: Journal Entry, Day 75, subscribe to email updates or our RSS Feed. You'll be notified when we next publish a story about the Old World.

25 Responses to “India’s Touts: Journal Entry, Day 75”

  1. I have to make a slight correction: This was our angriest day in India during THIS trip. The day I almost threw a bookshelf at someone was – you could say – my angriest.

  2. Hi Ian and Claire wow really enjoyed reading that keep going and go safe

  3. Frank says:

    Can`t say after reading this that a visit to India appeals to me.Interesting country,I`m sure,but not my idea of an enjoyable destination.

    Nice Post !

    • Iain Manley says:

      India is a big country. There is much less hassling in the south and the far north. I'm not sure why people on the plains are so hard-bitten. Perhaps because so many invaders have passed through. Perhaps because population pressure is at its most intense in the north. The two have also influenced what is an amazingly rich, vibrant material culture.

  4. Liz Biggs says:

    I sympathise. Being continually harrassed for money does take the edge off the adventure. It's one thing to develop a thick skin and shake off vendors that cling to your arms as you pass, but when you are having to try and negotiate a fair transportation deal with people whose only intention is to suck you drier than a Utah diner, it can be very frustrating and anger provoking. On the bright side, you will remember what you saw and did long after the anger has subsided. Well – maybe you will. You might just have to take anger managerment classes along with JuJu when you get home!

    I did love scene where you played traffic cop Iain. Priceless.

  5. Suresh says:

    It is not lack of education, it's culture. During my trips to India, I have met educated and successful Indians who have made criminal propositions to me to make easy money. To them it's a way of life and I felt as if someone slapped me. In India, money is the sole motive and how you make it does not matter. People at the lower rung will try to extract small amounts that they are not entitled to and people at the other end go for much larger sums but the idea is the same. Materialist west and spiritual east is a hogwash. I have met many god fearing, kind, generous, helpful and good people in USA but I can not say the same about India. Our two week trip to India recently with some of our American friends had many unpleasant experiences of theft, hostility and extortion. And all that happened while at five start hotels in nice parts of Delhi and dealing with so called religious men. I witnessed a religious man conduct ceremony which was nothing but a long drawn out extortion ritual. He just kept on going around demanding everyone put money to gratify gods! He had no shame and no one present could say no to parting with money because that would mean angering gods. I wouldn't be surprised if this man and his cohorts later on laughed at how easily they made us empty our wallets. We felt stupid as we should but that is how it goes when confronted with religious ceremonies created long ago by Brahmins for their own benefit! Iain, world is enormous with lots of nice places to visit and enjoy. Ask yourself this simple question "Why go through all this in India?"

    • Heather says:

      Hi Suresh

      I love your statement "Materialist west and spiritual east is a hogwash". Indeed – a hogwash.

      But your question "Why go through all this in India?" deeply worries me. We (of the west) must all go to India in order to understand multi-dimension-"ality". India is a great teacher and I suspect that – despite their disenchantment – Claire and Iain will return many times to India in their lifetimes.

  6. Fabrizio says:

    great story, and I think that your closing feelings are particularly good at tying the whole thing together. It is odd to be torn between that feeling of guilt and the feeling of anger. I always leave that kind of situation feeling like I did the wrong thing, but didn't have much choice in feeling otherwise.

  7. This is totally indicative of how I felt much of the time in India, and very eloquently told I might add. Not just bargaining either but just walking down the street. It got to the point where every "Hello suh, where from" from a shop entry made my fists tighten. I knew their curiosity about my foreigness was overshadowed by their interest in making a rupee off the ignorant traveler with the camera. Sometimes I'd play along. If I was tired and irritated, I'd ignore it if at all possible. Haggling for rides notwithstanding. I'm sure I lost a lot of money on many of those transactions.

    On the flipside, when there WAS an honest connection with a local, over tea or whatever, and it did happen, I felt truly enlightened walking away from it. But I've talked to a few people and the being taken advantage of issue in India is always point of contention.

    • Iain Manley says:

      Thanks Nico. I've been shown kindness by people from all walks of life in every part of India, and I think of these people when I realise that my writing is confirming people's negative perceptions of the country.

  8. Suresh says:

    I was looking at the situations described here from my perspective. We have been traveling for years and still there are many countries worth visiting that we haven't visited. When we travel, we like to be in the midst of pleasant and interesting surroundings, be treated nicely, drink good wine, eat good food and be transported around safely and comfortably. Last month we went to Brazil & Argentina and last year Peru, Austria, Switzerland & Italy. All these trips met or exceeded our expectations and recharged us to get back to work. India, however, is a different story. During one trip, my wife tried street food despite my objection and she went temporarily blind! A doctor friend of ours, after a trip to India which involved bath in the holy Ganges, acquired a nervous disease that put him in a wheelchair unable to work along with his wife, also a doctor, who now takes care of him full time. I would not take exception with intellectual pursuit you, Iain and Claire are indulging in but I guess, I am wired differently.

    • Iain Manley says:

      Suresh and Heather,

      Thank you both for your thoughtful comments. I think there is an important distinction between your holidays, Suresh, and the way we're travelling. I don't mean that you have seen or understood any less of the world than me. The opposite is probably true. But I am not on a holiday. I am travelling to discover the world around me, be it pleasant or painful. Your comments do validate my feelings, and for that I'm grateful.

      I'm afraid to that you are right Heather – I think my relationship with India will be lifelong. But I have sworn to be more discerning when I visit the country again: I don't think I'll return to any place in the north other than Varanasi and Gujarat, unless I'm just passing through. Himalayan India and the south are much more welcoming, and I've fought with enough rickshaw drivers for now. I also don't think I'd like to return as a tourist. If I go back, I'd like to spend time studying Hindi and perhaps find a job. You can only learn so much about a place without stopping. My life in China was much more pampered, but I think I understand the country better, because I was able to find my place in it.

  9. Kevin says:

    Great read! Thanks! This is about what I expect from India and what keeps me from going there. After so many years of traveling, I think I am just looking to be left alone. I can go to Burma and not be harrassed and Syria, as you also found, is extraordinarily generous and welcoming at all levels of society. Is this overpopulation's effect on a culture? That "skip the line, push, grab, steal or go hungry" lifestyle? I have similar problems in Mainland China while a visit to Taiwan is the complete opposite experience on the bell curve of kindness. That tinge of guilt you felt at the end is what always ends up staying with me. I eventually lose my cool and say something or do something I regret as a conscientious human being. Most likely the victim of my overreaction, on the other hand, will never remember it because it's just another day in a dog-eat-dog world.

    • Iain Manley says:

      Thanks Kevin. This was a single day in a single place. India is big and extraordinary, which is why I have chosen to spend a long time there. Read some of our articles about the good days – perhaps this or this – and don't write the place off. I think that anybody who considers themselves well-travelled must visit India at some stage.

  10. Heather says:

    Suresh – thanks for elaborating. I do indeed see your point of view and admit that mine is probably naive – I'm still in the enchanted phase!

  11. ChrisZ says:

    I remember someone said:"I would not bother over some petty money this time, it's not worth it, I will just pay and get what I want."

    But of course Ian's right, the way they treat you, it's not at all about money.

    But! but!! Some people enjoys bargain, take it this way: it's just another healthy way of communication :P

    • Iain Manley says:

      Chris, if you write those words down, I'll make sure Claire eats them when we get back to Shanghai.

      I don't think that the fights we've had are a healthy form of communication. If you bargain and you get a fair price, you feel good. But when the only price you're ever offered is an insult to your intelligence, and an attempt to prey on your weakness, nobody is having healthy fun. I think that there is an undercurrent of strongfelt resentment in India, against rich Westerners who can flit in, marvel at the noise, the colour and the poverty, then flit out. Claire and I were abused by a woman at the check-in desk at Calcutta airport for no good reason. She had nothing to gain from mistreating us, but she made our lives as difficult as possible just because she could, just because for a few minutes we were under her power.

    • I almost forgot what you have so aptly reminded me of, Chris. You are right: I said exactly that. In fact, I think I might have been telling you the story of the bookshelf that I got the urge to pick up and throw in my sheer rage in a Delhi post office. A ten or twenty rupee bribe would have gotten my parcel sent and had me out of there hours before with my sanity in tact. But once again, during these last few months, I still let myself get angry and have never resorted to paying a bribe.

  12. Neil says:

    This story brought back many unhappy memories from Egypt, where there's a similar attitude to foreigners as being little more than the contents of their wallets. I hated it there, and stories of similar behaviour have been keeping me from giving India a go.

    It's not just the constant requests for money – it's what they do to me. In Egypt, my first reaction when someone started talking to me was to say "no." It was a habit that took several weeks to break when we moved on to neighbouring, friendlier, countries, and I still get a bit of a hostile shell when traveling in developing countries, and I often regret it.

    And there's little benefit to just paying the 10-rupee premium. They'll just ask the next foreigner for even more.

    • Iain Manley says:

      We were hassled in Egypt too. Take a look at Tout Like an Egyptian. My memory has a way of distorting a country's petty hassles, but I'd say Egypt along the Nile, was far worse than anywhere in India.

      I've heard that if you stay away from the most travelled parts of the country, the people are warm and hospitable. The same is true of India: if you don't want to be hassled, go to the south or far north. There are fewer famous monuments, but it's much easier to engage with the locals.

  13. We had a much rougher go of it in Morocco than India. Especially Fez. You are not just hassled constantly, but are also a target for elaborate schemes dressed like friendly advice or conversation, in unlikely locations. (As in, not just when looking for city transport, or booking a tour, or shopping/walking in the souks.) It was completely brutal.

    We still have incredibly fond memories of Morocco, though. Somewhat surprisingly. And have mentioned more than once that we'll go back. Even so, just thinking about some of the brazen ruses, and aggressive hassling, makes my blood boil a bit.

    Course perhaps the most brazen ripoff did occur in India – by customs at the Mumbai airport of all places. Tried to take me for $200 for having my own camera with me. After they took me into a back room, and took my passport, I managed to get away with just $50. It was still bullshit, as I found out later. There's no tax for bringing in your own damn camera. I should've known when they were willing to haggle, but after a super long flight, I was in no shape for it.)

  14. Seri says:

    I loved your entry and found it very entertaining! However, may I make a suggestion? Your writing is so animated that I find myself trying to picture the landscapes, as well as the faces of those you encountered. I would love it if you could post more pictures or video to accompany your pieces. Take care and enjoy the rest of your travels!

  15. Iain says:

    Thanks Seri. We do normally post the best of our photos, but there aren't many of this particular afternoon.

Leave a Reply

Comment Policy

We welcome encouragement, questions and advice. Perhaps welcome isn't strong enough. Comments are the best and more or less only reward we receive for putting Old World Wandering together. We're addicted to the words at the end of an article because they, A, tell us you got that far and, hopefully, B, enjoyed getting there. But please stick to the topic and use your real name or a nickname. Generic comments submitted for SEO purposes will be deleted.

Top